Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You are un-fireable for the usual reasons for which people outside academia worry about being fired.

Layoffs aren't a thing in academia. Poor performance in the classroom isn't punishable. Failure to bring in grants isn't punishable. You can't be fired for disagreeing with your boss. You can (in most cases) publicly criticize the administration you work for, and advocate for many (yes, not all) controversial ideas.



That's an American thing. By default, you can fire anyone at any time for no reason. Universities then overcompensate and give extensive protections for tenured faculty.

In Europe, it's more common that a professor has roughly the same job security as a teenager in their first real job. There are some exceptions due to academic freedom, but they are mostly about the substance of the work rather than the performance in it. And other independent professionals, such as doctors, lawyers, and civil engineers, often have similar exceptions.


This is totally not true in my country (UK). Staff are laid off. Tenure doesn't exist. Departments are not closed.


But thats UK, a small backwater island


A small backwater island with 4 universities in the top 10 of worldwide rankings and outperformance in the top 100 too?


yeah


They are, but extremely infrequently and when they are it is minor numbers, at least at the largest universities. And when they are laid off it is for financial reasons not performance.


Not sure if you're following the news, but almost every university is in financial trouble at the moment.


> Layoffs aren't a thing in academia

May not "layoffs", but schools lose funding, get shut down, and fail to track sufficient students to justify continuing employment.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact