2
$\begingroup$

consider the set of lines defined by all pairs of points $\lbrace[(u,v),(u-v,v+u)],\ u,v\in\mathbb{N}\rbrace$ in the euclidean plane

Question:

what is kown about the density of the set of intersection-points of pairs of non-identical lines from the set of lines as defined above

  • is this set of intersection points dense in the first quadrant
  • what can be said about their density/distribution
$\endgroup$

1 Answer 1

3
$\begingroup$

is this set of intersection points dense in the first quadrant

No. Indeed, let $\ell_{u,v}$ be the line through the points $(u,v),(u-v,v+u)$. The point of intersection of distinct nonparallel lines $\ell_{u,v}$ and $\ell_{x,y}$ is $$p_{u,v,x,y}:= \frac1{uy-vx}\,\big((u^2+v^2)y-(x^2+y^2)v,(x^2+y^2)u-(u^2+v^2)x\big),$$ with $uy-vx\ne0$.

Proposition 1: For any real $a>0$, $b>0$, $u\ge0$, $v\ge0$, $x\ge0$, and $y\ge0$ such that $p_{u,v,x,y}=(a,b)$, one must have $u\le a+b$ and $v\le a+b$ and hence, by symmetry, $x\le a+b$ and $y\le a+b$.

See the proof of Proposition 1 below.

By Proposition 1, for any real $R>0$, the set $S_R:=\{p_{u,v,x,y}\in(0,R]^2\colon u,v,x,y\text{ in }\Bbb N\}$ is of cardinality $\le(R+R+1)^4<\infty$, so that the set $S:=\{p_{u,v,x,y}\colon u,v,x,y\text{ in }\Bbb N\}$ is not dense in $(0,R]^2$. In fact, being locally finite, the set $S$ is nowhere dense in the first quadrant. $\quad\Box$

Proof of Proposition 1: This is a problem of real algebraic geometry, which therefore admits a purely algorithmic solution. Such algorithms are realized in Mathematica by commands such as Reduce. Using this command, in about 0.12 sec we get

enter image description here

$\Box$


Proposition 1 can also be proved by hand, by considering four rather simple cases to prove that $u\le a+b$, depending on the signs of $uy-vx$ and $u-v$, and similar four cases to prove that $v\le a+b$, and using certain convexity and monotonicity patterns. That proof is quite elementary but long and tedious.

$\endgroup$

You must log in to answer this question.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.