[book] routing ch review, part 1 #6354
Conversation
| | ||
| This is the goal of the Symfony router: to map the URL of a request to a | ||
| controller. Along the way, you'll learn all sorts of tricks that make mapping | ||
| even the most complex URLs easy. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Ah, but we could probably keep this section and delete everything else - this is the heart of this document :). If I understand it correctly, now the first routing example will be very far down on the page, after a lot of boring paragraphs (people skip this mostly and look for code blocks).
In other words, I think this should stay!
There was a problem hiding this comment.
To explain my proposed changes. Before my proposed change the chapter looked like this:
First there was "Routing in Action" sub-title with @Route("/blog/{slug}", name="blog_show") example and upper description. Then there were request flow and some configuration sub-titles fallowed by "Basic Route Configuration" sub-title with @Route("/") routing example. The thing that bothered me was that after all this there was "Routing with Placeholders" sub-title with exactly the same example as "Routing in Action" sub-title. So both subtitles were essentially the same and more complex example @Route("/blog/{slug}", name="blog_show") was before more simple one @Route("/") and to a beginner example explanation therefore probably didn't make much sense until latter. This is the reason i proposed the squash of the two sub-titles - "Basic Route Configuration" and "Routing with Placeholders". Nothing was removed. The explanation in this squashed sub-title is even better then before and the chapter flow now progresses from easy and simple to more complex examples instead of from complex (with no background) to simple and to more complex again... So the heart of this chapter was not removed just improved but yes, like you said, moved just a little bit further down but i still don't think that further down (lines 202-311) :)
| Hey @paxyknox! I just made some comments on this PR and the next one. Can you update them? Honestly, these contain some good changes, but they are a lot of work to review - it's all I've been doing for about 1 hour now :). If you're able to make some changes "smaller" - i.e. keep the most important ones, it will help to review them. But thank you for the contributions - I just want to make sure we are able to review things efficiently - we have short time. |
| I made suggested changes. Yes, I almost have a bad consciousness because these chapters are so big and therefore there is much to review. But i could't do this just partially. I think it deserves a proper improvement as a hole - for all of us. :) |
| Closing: see #6252 (comment) |
2 participants
Among other things I squashed subtitle "Routing in Action" with "Routing with Placeholders" since it was dealing with the same thing - the same code example.