Skip to content
Open
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
169 changes: 169 additions & 0 deletions IMPROVEMENT_SUMMARY.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,169 @@
# Better Error Messages - Implementation Summary

## Overview

This implementation provides the first step in the React on Rails incremental improvements plan: **Better Error Messages with actionable solutions**.

## Changes Made

### 1. SmartError Class (`lib/react_on_rails/smart_error.rb`)

- New intelligent error class that provides contextual help
- Supports multiple error types:
- `component_not_registered` - Component registration issues
- `missing_auto_loaded_bundle` - Auto-loaded bundle missing
- `hydration_mismatch` - Server/client render mismatch
- `server_rendering_error` - SSR failures
- `redux_store_not_found` - Redux store issues
- `configuration_error` - Configuration problems
- Features:
- Suggests similar component names for typos
- Provides specific code examples for fixes
- Includes colored output for better readability
- Shows context-aware troubleshooting steps

### 2. Enhanced PrerenderError (`lib/react_on_rails/prerender_error.rb`)

- Improved error formatting with colored headers
- Pattern-based error detection for common issues:
- `window is not defined` - Browser API on server
- `document is not defined` - DOM API on server
- Undefined/null errors - Missing props or data
- Hydration errors - Server/client mismatch
- Specific solutions for each error pattern
- Better organization of error information

### 3. Component Registration Debugging (JavaScript)

- New debug options in `ReactOnRails.setOptions()`:
- `debugMode` - Full debug logging
- `logComponentRegistration` - Component registration details
- Logging includes:
- Component names being registered
- Registration timing (performance metrics)
- Component sizes (approximate)
- Registration success confirmations

### 4. Helper Module Updates (`lib/react_on_rails/helper.rb`)

- Integrated SmartError for auto-loaded bundle errors
- Required smart_error module

### 5. TypeScript Types (`node_package/src/types/index.ts`)

- Added type definitions for new debug options
- Documented debug mode and registration logging options

### 6. Tests

- Ruby tests (`spec/react_on_rails/smart_error_spec.rb`)
- Tests for each error type
- Validation of error messages and solutions
- Context information tests
- JavaScript tests (`node_package/tests/debugLogging.test.js`)
- Component registration logging tests
- Debug mode option tests
- Timing information validation

### 7. Documentation (`docs/guides/improved-error-messages.md`)

- Complete guide on using new error features
- Examples of each error type
- Debug mode configuration
- Troubleshooting checklist

## Benefits

### For Developers

1. **Faster debugging** - Errors now tell you exactly what to do
2. **Less context switching** - Solutions are provided inline
3. **Typo detection** - Suggests correct component names
4. **Performance insights** - Registration timing helps identify slow components
5. **Better visibility** - Debug mode shows what's happening under the hood

### Examples of Improvements

#### Before:

```text
Component HelloWorld not found
```

#### After (Updated with Auto-Bundling Priority):

```text
❌ React on Rails Error: Component 'HelloWorld' Not Registered

Component 'HelloWorld' was not found in the component registry.

React on Rails offers two approaches:
• Auto-bundling (recommended): Components load automatically, no registration needed
• Manual registration: Traditional approach requiring explicit registration

💡 Suggested Solution:
Did you mean one of these? HelloWorldApp, HelloWorldComponent

🚀 Recommended: Use Auto-Bundling (No Registration Required!)

1. Enable auto-bundling in your view:
<%= react_component("HelloWorld", props: {}, auto_load_bundle: true) %>

2. Place your component in the components directory:
app/javascript/components/HelloWorld/HelloWorld.jsx

3. Generate the bundle:
bundle exec rake react_on_rails:generate_packs

✨ That's it! No manual registration needed.
```

### Key Innovation: Auto-Bundling as Primary Solution

The improved error messages now **prioritize React on Rails' auto-bundling feature**, which completely eliminates the need for manual component registration. This is a significant improvement because:

1. **Simpler for developers** - No need to maintain registration files
2. **Automatic code splitting** - Each component gets its own bundle
3. **Better organization** - Components are self-contained in their directories
4. **Reduced errors** - No forgetting to register components

## Usage

### Enable Debug Mode (JavaScript)

```javascript
// In your entry file
ReactOnRails.setOptions({
debugMode: true,
logComponentRegistration: true,
});
```

### View Enhanced Errors (Rails)

Errors are automatically enhanced - no configuration needed. For full details:

```ruby
ENV["FULL_TEXT_ERRORS"] = "true"
```

## Next Steps

This is Phase 1 of the incremental improvements. Next phases include:

- Enhanced Doctor Command (Phase 1.2)
- Modern Generator Templates (Phase 2.1)
- Rspack Migration Assistant (Phase 3.1)
- Inertia-Style Controller Helpers (Phase 5.1)

## Testing

Due to Ruby version constraints on the system (Ruby 2.6, project requires 3.0+), full testing wasn't completed, but:

- JavaScript builds successfully
- Code structure follows existing patterns
- Tests are provided for validation

## Impact

This change has **High Impact** with **Low Effort** (2-3 days), making it an ideal first improvement. It immediately improves the developer experience without requiring any migration or configuration changes.
Loading
Loading