Threading timer crashes my App

[panoss]

I want to make an app that will use timer.
A button will set the timer at my pc 's time plus one minute.
The problem is that it crashes.
Run the following code and press button 'set alarm'.
Then try to close the form clicking the close button ('x') of the form.
It freezes.

I guess I'm not using correctly the threading?

Any good working solution?

import sys from PyQt4 import QtGui import os import threading import datetime import pygame class MyApp(QtGui.QWidget):    def __init__(self):        QtGui.QMainWindow.__init__(self)        pygame.init()        pygame.mixer.init()        now = datetime.datetime.now()        hour = now.hour; minute = now.minute; second = now.second        # add pusbutton        self.set_alarm_btn = QtGui.QPushButton('set_alarm_btn', self)        self.set_alarm_btn.clicked.connect(self._set_alarm_btn_clicked)        layout = QtGui.QVBoxLayout(self)        layout.addWidget(self.set_alarm_btn)    def _set_alarm_btn_clicked(self):        now = datetime.datetime.now()        hour = now.hour;        minute = now.minute;        second = now.second        self.clock = Clock()        self.clock.set_alarm(hour, minute + 1, self)        self.clock.run()    def _response_to_alert(args):        print("Alert")    def ring_ring(self):        sys.stdout.write('ring ring\n')        sys.stdout.flush()        if  hasattr(self, 'clock'):            self.clock._alarm_thread.cancel() class Clock:    def __init__(self):        self.alarm_time = None        self._alarm_thread = None        self.update_interval = 1        self.event = threading.Event()    def run(self):        while True:            self.event.wait(self.update_interval)            if self.event.isSet():                break            now = datetime.datetime.now()            if self._alarm_thread and self._alarm_thread.is_alive():                alarm_symbol = '+'            else:                alarm_symbol = ' '            sys.stdout.write("\r%02d:%02d:%02d %s"                % (now.hour, now.minute, now.second, alarm_symbol))            sys.stdout.flush()    def set_alarm(self, hour, minute, parent):        now = datetime.datetime.now()        alarm = now.replace(hour=int(hour), minute=int(minute))        delta = int((alarm - now).total_seconds())        if delta <= 0:            alarm = alarm.replace(day=alarm.day + 1)            delta = int((alarm - now).total_seconds())        if self._alarm_thread:            self._alarm_thread.cancel()        self._alarm_thread = threading.Timer(delta, parent.ring_ring)        self._alarm_thread.daemon = True        self._alarm_thread.start() if __name__ == '__main__':    app = QtGui.QApplication(sys.argv)    window = MyApp()    window.show()    sys.exit(app.exec_())

[Ofnuts]

A windowed application has an "event loop". Conceptually it polls a queue of events (mouse and keyboard, mostly), processes the event, and then polls for the next event. A good deal of the events is processed by the UI support (the Qt library, in your case), but some are forwarded to your app (_set_alarm_btn_clicked). If your code doesn't return quickly, the event loop gets stuck, doesn't poll further events, so you application no longer reacts to events and your UI freezes.

So you have to wonder what happens when you call  clock.run()....

In practice, any code that takes a significant amount of time (>.1 second) should be delegated to a thread. That thread then communicates with the event loop thread by sending it events. Not a PyQt expert, but this looks like the answer.

PS: future-proofing: have you checked that you can use pygame and pyqt4 in the same application without getting conflicts?

[metulburr]

PS: future-proofing: have you checked that you can use pygame and pyqt4 in the same application without getting conflicts?

First of all...Your asking for trouble when you mix two GUI libraries. Im not sure specifically about pyqt4 mixed with pygame though. Like I know that pygame and tkinter dont work well together.
Second of all why are you using two libraries? Your using pygame's mixer but pyqt4 GUI for the button. Why not just use pygame for both?

[panoss]

I started using PyQt4 only, without pygame.
Then I added pygame because I wanted to play some mp3 files and looked very easy with pygame.
I didn't know that there might be some conflict between them.

[nilamo]

       pygame.init()
       pygame.mixer.init()

You don't use all of pygame, so don't init all of pygame. That'll init the graphics devices, which you specifically don't want to do since you're using Qt. pygame's made pretty modular, so as long as you only init the mixer, you should be able to use just the mixer without issues.

   def run(self):
       while True:
           self.event.wait(self.update_interval)
           if self.event.isSet():
               break

Could the reason that it freezes be that you're waiting for the event to be .isSet(), but you never actually set() the event? So it just keeps looping forever.
It's interesting that you're using threading.Event, but you're never actually starting a new thread, except for the alarm_thread, which doesn't seem to serve any purpose other than to eventually get cancelled (ie: it's basically just a True/False that's unnecessarily complicated).