Which sound is better

I was wondering what sound is better for guns like this, should it be loud or should it be like in csgo/cs2 idk that much on sound design plz help.

This One:

Or this one:

2 Likes

I’m no expert but I prefer the first one.

3 Likes

I feel like the second sounds more realistic while the first sounds more punchier.
I also feel like the second one should have more high end frequencies though, just my opinion.
Overall, I prefer the second sound.

I’d suggest you to choose neither of those options and instead opt for something with a higher pitch. A gunshot isn’t only bass, it’s a tiny explosion and hence it should have a higher pitch to it.

4 Likes

Here’s a real sound I just recorded on my Glock 17. The sound quality is poor and not necessarily intended for use, but it’s just to give you an idea. You can add a random pitch to each shot to remove the repetitive aspect of the sound.

2 Likes

try use the soundID 801217802, will sound better than both of those

the first one sounds more fit for games, the second one sounds more realistic

overall i prefer the first one

These both don’t sound good, they sound like they were shot 50 meters away and behind a brick wall, despite the gun being in your hand.

1 Like

yeah that sure does sound different, but what if it was shot on an open space, should i use hickok45 guntesting sounds?